Showing posts with label first. Show all posts
Showing posts with label first. Show all posts

January 05, 2021

To the best of Nanox knowledge

Nanox (and predecessor) "first" press releases are quite amusing - Singapore detector in October 2013, digital 1x1x1 in June 2019, and the field of cones, November 2019.

So, Mr. Masuya, a lawyer and the founder and CEO of Nanox predecessor, says in November 2019:

to the best of our knowledge no company have achieved a commercially stable [cold cathode] source [based on carbon nano tubes] that can be embedded inside a medical imaging system and operate with an acceptable lifespan. 


The problem is that he must have known that Carestream and Micro-X had received clearance for and commercialized their Nano x-ray system with a cold-cathode source based on carbon nano tubes in February 2018.  That source was initially made by XinRay (a Siemens JV now defunct, but see NuRay), and now by Micro-X Ltd.  So much for Nanox "knowledge."  


Micro-X CNT source ( from https://www.aumanufacturing.com.au/micro-xs-carbon-nanotube-x-ray-machine-in-clinical-use )

And where is that Nanox source that can be embedded inside a medical imaging system and operate with an acceptable lifespan?  Or did he mean a cheap underpowered hot-cathode Chinese source not suitable for medical imaging? 

Note:  High current with a maximum emitter current of 130mA for up to 2 seconds per tech page.  Compare to Nanox 11mA "proposed" hand-made "hight [sic]" chart. 


December 29, 2020

First digital source

 In its "first" press release issued in November 2019,  Nanox says:

Nanox, founded by the serial entrepreneur Ran Poliakine, is an Israeli/Japanese cooperation that has created the world’s first commercial-grade digital X-ray source for real-world medical imaging applications

How do you define digital? Roentgen used a cold-cathode (gas discharge) tube when he discovered X-rays, and so did all commercial X-ray sources until 1913.  Carestream/Micro-X/XinRay got clearance for the mobile x-ray unit that uses CNT tubes in February 2018. 


Crookes tube, source:  https://www.emory.edu/X-RAYS/century_02.htm
 

Update March 31, 2021:  Vatech got clearance for its dental x-ray system that uses a CNT tube (V1-650304in September 2016.